The authors have conducted a comparative-legal analysis of criminal responsibility for sabotage in conformity with the criminal legislations of Tajikistan and Ukraine on the object of crime. In modern criminal law the method of criminal jurisprudence has become one of leading and universal in the system of a methodological base of scientific research. According to the Criminal Code of Ukraine a generic and specific object of sabotage is national security of the country, but TR CC has distinctions as there are public relations in the sphere of state power being a generic object and a specific object is state security. It is well-grounded that TR CC practice is more correct as the notion “national security” has a wide meaning and in general it can become a generic object of the entire corpus delicti according to Especial part of Ukraine Criminal Code. As a result, taking into account some positive items of article 113 of the Criminal Code of Ukraine a new version of article 309 of TR CC is proposed.
securityof state, object; threat tonational security, state defense capability; economic security
1) Tulyakov V. A. Comparative Method in the Science of Criminal Law / V.O. Tulyakov // Bulletin of the Association of Criminal Law of Ukraine, 2014, - № 1 (2). – pp. 29-35
2) Ingthorsson R.D. The Natural vs. The Human Sciences: Myth, Methodology and Ontology [Text] / R.D. Ingthorsson // Discusiones Filosóficas. – №. 22. – January – June. - 2013.
3) Serdyuk PP The Theory of Criminal Liability in Modern Criminal Law: a Comparative-Legal Invertigation: Doctoral dissertation in jurisprudence. - Zaporozhye, 2013. - 463 pp.
4) Savchenko A. V. The Concept of Comparative Criminal Law and General Characteristics of the Major Contemporary Legal Families [Text] / Multimedia textbook Manual "Criminal Law: Common Part” [Electronic resource]. - Access mode http://www.naiau.kiev.ua/books/mnp_krum_prav_zag/Files/Lekc/T21/T21_P1.html. (Date of access 10/01/2020)
5) Art. 113 of the Criminal Code of Ukraine, Art. 303 of the Criminal Code of the Republic of Armenia
6) Klimosyuk A. S. Criminal Liability for Sabotage. (in Ukrainian). / A.S. Klimosyuk. Candidate dissertation in jurisprudence. - Kharkov. 2018. - 247 pp.
7) Criminal Law of Ukraine. Common Part: textbook (Criminal law of Ukraine. Common part: textbook) / under the editorship of. V.Ya. Tatsiy, V. I. Borisov, VI Tyutyugin. The 5-th edition, revised and enlarged. - Kharkov: Law. - 2015. - 528 pp. (in Ukranian)
8) Scientifico-Practical Commentary on the Criminal Code of Ukraine. Especial part. Under the editorship of Potebenko M. O. Goncharenko V. G. - Kiev: Forum. - 2002. - 987 pp.
9) Scientifico-Practical Commentary on the Criminal Code of Ukraine. / under the editorship of S. S. Yatsenko. –K.: A.S.K. - 2002, - 936 pp.
10) Scientifico-Practical Commentary on the Criminal Code of Ukraine. / under the editorship of W. E. Melnik, M. I. Khavronyuk. – K.: Canon. - 2001. - 1104 pp.
11) Kudratov N. A. Crimes against the Foundations of the Constitutional Order and Security of the State. Tutorial. / N. A. Kudratov. - Dushanbe, 2019. - 235 p.; Kudratov N. A. On the Definition of the Notion "Diversion" and its Object / N. A. Kudratov // Bulletin of the Tajik National University. Series of Socio-Economic and Social Sciences. 2018, # 9. 289-294.pp
12) Tatsiy V.Ya. Object and Subject of Crime in the Criminal Law of Ukraine: monograph. (in Ukrainian.) / V.Ya. Tacia. - Kharkov: Law, 2016. - 256 pp.
Bantyshev O. F. Criminal Liability for Crimes versus the National Security of Ukraine (qualification problems): monograph. (in Ukrainian). O. F. Bantyshev, O. V. Shamara. - Lugansk: Virtual Reality, 2014. - 198 pp